|
Memory Timings:
Don't matter much
By HMJ
Virtualjesus23@mail.com
The last time I
started a system build one of the last pieces of hardware I bought was the RAM.
Buying memory is difficult because of all the little things associated with it.
You have multiple types of RAM, ram speed, and of course memory timings, which is
what I am taking a look at today
To take a look at how
RAM timings affect overall system performance, I have done some tests comparing
and contrasting the performance increases and decreases associated with changing
certain memory timings while leaving others alone, in order to test each
individual timings effect on the memory as a whole. This sounds confusing I
know, but wait, it will all be made clear.
For these tests I used
Twin 512 MB sticks of DDR3200 Crucial Ballistix, in a DFI Lanparty Ulta-D
mainboard, with an AMD Athlon 64 3000+ Overclocked to 2610MHZ (290*9), and an
ATI x850 XT. Just as a note incase your curious my memory is running at DDR 266
speed utilizing the onboard memory divider at 133 MHz.
Note: For this article I am going to use the pretty well
standard labeling or ram timings as such:
2.5, 2, 2, 6 (random example)
Cas, Trcd, Trp, and Tras respectively
Note: if you dont know
what those mean, neither do I, but thats probably how they are labeled in your
bios.
CAS
(cas latency)
|
|
2,2,2,5 |
2.5,2,2,5 |
3,2,2,5 |
|
Rightmark Triad Avg. |
2765 |
2774 |
2753 |
|
ScienceMark Cipher |
10.6 |
10.7 |
10.7 |
|
Sandra 05 Memory |
5433 |
5425 |
5416 |
|
Doom III* |
51.6 FPS |
51.5 FPS |
51.6 FPS |
Doom III run at High
Detail 1280*960
Sad to say, despite my
standard opinions regarding memory timings, especially CAS, non of these
fluctuations are outside of the range of random performance difference from one
restart to the next. Maybe TRCD will fair better.
TRCD
|
|
2,2,2,5 |
2,3,2,5 |
2,4,2,5 |
2,5,2,5 |
|
Rightmark Triad Avg. |
2765 |
2794 |
2765 |
2729 |
|
ScienceMark Cipher |
10.6 |
10.7 |
10.7 |
10.7 |
|
Sandra 05 Memory |
5433 |
5433 |
5408 |
5388 |
|
Doom III |
51.6 FPS |
51.6 FPS |
51.6 FPS |
51.6 FPS |
Although slightly more
of a difference than shown by the CAS, it is nothing extra ordinary and a
similar effect could be garnered in any system via a bad restart or a few extra
processes running in the background.
TRP
|
|
2,2,2,5 |
2,2,3,5 |
2,2,4,5 |
2,2,5,5 |
|
Rightmark Triad Avg. |
2765 |
2791 |
2779 |
2720 |
|
ScienceMark Cipher |
10.6 |
10.7 |
10.6 |
10.7 |
|
Sandra 05 Memory |
5433 |
5439 |
5420 |
5399 |
|
Doom III |
51.6 FPS |
51.6 FPS |
51.6 FPS |
51.6 FPS |
I dont feel the need
to address this set of data, sufficient to say that it falls under a similar
category as the other two timings.
TRAS
|
|
2,2,2,5 |
2,2,2,6 |
2,2,2,7 |
|
Rightmark Triad Avg. |
2765 |
2794 |
2803 |
|
ScienceMark Cipher |
10.6 |
10.7 |
10.7 |
|
Sandra 05 Memory |
5433 |
5429 |
5434 |
|
Doom III |
51.6 FPS |
51.5 FPS |
51.6 FPS |
Ok still nothing, just one thing left to try, maybe the
over all effect of the timings will be cumulative and if you have all crappy
timings, performance will sufferlets see.
|
|
Good (2,2,2,5) |
Crappy (3,5,5,7) |
|
Rightmark Triad Avg. |
2765 |
2584 |
|
ScienceMark Cipher |
10.6 |
10.7 |
|
Sandra 05 Memory |
5433 |
5285 |
|
Doom III |
51.6 FPS |
51.6 FPS |
Here we see a little
something but nothing all that big especially on the non synthetic bench in
which we see no change whatsoever.
Mmmm'k this tells me
one thing, memory timings dont mean much of crap. Due to the data I have
collected I have decided that as long as you buy good brand name ram with good
chips you should be good to go. Now this may be a forgone conclusion
considering I havent gotten to test any cheaper ram as compared to my Ballistix
which is one of the best brands out there. Cheaper ram may very well suffer from
massive performance loss as memory timings are lessened. Additionally my rather
substantial over clock may have something to do with the lack of performance
loss, but I doubt it; usually over clocking makes the rams job an ass load
harder not a bunch easier.
Remember Kids
the moral of the story is; dont pay out the ass for timings, instead save your
money for good name brand stuff. Youll do better in the long run.
HMJ
|